Personal loan guide India: is a loan the right tool?
The technique
Price the loan as the cost of time
A personal loan does not make anything affordable that was not affordable before. It moves the purchase earlier and charges for the months it moved. The useful question is how many months earlier, at what price, set against the other ways of paying: money already saved, a card spend converted to EMI, or an advance on salary.
Take the other routes first. Spending a deposit you already hold: ₹2 lakh in an FD at an illustrative 7 percent earns ₹14,000 in a year, ₹9,800 after tax at a 30 percent slab. The 12-month loan costs ₹20,204, which is 2.06 times what the deposit would have earned. Borrowing to keep a deposit intact that earns less than the loan costs is paying ₹10,404 for the feeling of still having savings. The exception is an emergency fund: that money has a job, and a holiday is not it.
Converting a card spend to EMI at an illustrative 15 percent with a 1 percent fee costs ₹21,976 over 12 months once 18 percent GST on the interest is counted, ₹1,772 more than the loan, and it needs a limit the trip fits inside. On a ₹1,50,000 limit the card is ₹50,000 short, and a card run close to its limit shows as high utilisation on your credit report while the balance is carried.
A salary advance is two different things under one name. An advance from your employer, recovered from the next few salaries, is often interest-free and costs only a thinner payslip. A salary advance product from a lender is a short loan: an illustrative ₹1,200 fee on ₹40,000 for 30 days is ₹1,416 with GST, 3.54 percent for the month and 43.1 percent annualised. One month's interest on the same ₹40,000 at 14 percent is ₹467. It suits a gap of days before payday, not a trip.
| Way to pay for ₹2 lakh | What it costs | The catch |
|---|---|---|
| Spend an FD at 7% | ₹9,800 of interest forgone after tax | Not if it is your emergency fund |
| Personal loan, 12 months at 14% | ₹20,204 interest and fee | EMI of ₹17,957 |
| Personal loan, 24 months at 14% | ₹35,192 interest and fee | EMI of ₹9,603 for two years |
| Card EMI, 12 months at 15% | ₹21,976 with fee and GST | Needs a limit above the trip |
| Save for 8 months first | Earns ₹3,833 | The trip waits |
- If the money sits in a deposit that is not your emergency fund, using it beats every loan on this page by at least ₹10,404 on a 12-month view
- If the money will be back in your hands before a card's due date, the card's interest-free window beats all of these; the page on applying for a personal loan online works that case
- Otherwise the loan wins only on time. What it buys, against saving, is months, and the next section prices them






